Choosing the right pocket pistol is a deeply personal decision, hinging on factors like hand size, comfort, and intended use. Two models consistently topping "best pocket pistol" lists are Ruger's LCP (Lightweight Compact Pistol) and its successor, the LCP II. This in-depth comparison will dissect the key differences and help you determine which pistol best suits your needs.
Key Differences: LCP vs. LCP II
While both pistols share the same basic design philosophy—a lightweight, easily concealable .380 ACP—the LCP II boasts several significant improvements over its predecessor.
1. Trigger: A Night and Day Difference
The most noticeable upgrade in the LCP II is its significantly improved trigger. The LCP's trigger is notoriously stiff and heavy, often requiring considerable effort to pull. This can lead to accuracy issues and discomfort during practice. The LCP II, however, features a lighter, smoother trigger pull with a more defined reset, making it considerably more comfortable and accurate to shoot. This improvement alone is a major selling point for many shooters.
2. Improved Ergonomics and Grip
The LCP II boasts a redesigned grip that provides a more secure and comfortable hold. While the LCP's grip is functional, it's somewhat rudimentary. The LCP II's textured grip enhances control, reducing felt recoil and improving overall shootability. This is especially crucial for smaller-handed shooters.
3. Sights: Enhanced Visibility
While both pistols utilize basic sights, the LCP II's sights are slightly more prominent and easier to acquire, particularly in low-light conditions. This improvement, though subtle, can significantly impact accuracy and speed during a self-defense situation.
4. Reliability: Consistent Performance
Both the LCP and LCP II are generally considered reliable pistols. However, anecdotal evidence suggests that the LCP II experiences fewer malfunctions, particularly with different types of ammunition. This improved reliability contributes to the LCP II's overall appeal.
5. Weight and Dimensions: Minimal Changes
The weight and dimensions are very similar between the two models. The difference is negligible in terms of concealability and carry.
Which One Should You Choose?
The decision ultimately boils down to your priorities and budget.
-
Choose the Ruger LCP if: You're on a tight budget and prioritize affordability above all else. The LCP is a perfectly functional firearm, especially if you're comfortable with a stiffer trigger pull.
-
Choose the Ruger LCP II if: You value a smoother, lighter trigger, improved ergonomics, enhanced sights, and slightly improved reliability. The added cost is justified by the substantial improvements in shootability and overall user experience.
Beyond the Basics: Ammunition and Accessories
Regardless of your choice, remember that selecting the right ammunition is crucial for optimal performance and reliability. Experiment with different brands and types to determine what your pistol performs best with. Accessories like extended magazines and holsters can further enhance both comfort and functionality.
Conclusion: A Worthy Upgrade
The Ruger LCP II represents a significant improvement over the original LCP. While the LCP remains a viable option for budget-conscious buyers, the enhancements in the LCP II make it the superior choice for most shooters. The smoother trigger, improved ergonomics, and enhanced reliability translate to a more comfortable, accurate, and ultimately safer shooting experience. Consider your individual needs and priorities carefully before making your final decision.
